Culture Sins of antisemitism: Will France posthumously promote Alfred Dreyfus?

Sins of antisemitism: Will France posthumously promote Alfred Dreyfus?

-

- Advertisment -
ADVERTISEMENT

France’s National Assembly Defense Committee has unanimously approved a bill to posthumously promote Captain Alfred Dreyfus to the rank of brigadier general, marking a historic correction of the antisemitic injustice he endured.  

The bill comes 90 years after Dreyfus’ death and has been described as “an important step in the history of Alfred Dreyfus and in the history of the Republic,” according to Charles Sitzenstuhl, the Ensemble pour la république (EPR) MP for Bas-Rhin and the rapporteur for the bill.  

“The anti-Semitism that struck Alfred Dreyfus is not a thing of the past. Today’s acts of hatred are a reminder that this fight is still relevant today,” pointed out former Prime Minister Gabriel Attal, who tabled the bill on 7 May.  

The text also states that “five years of deportation and humiliation irreparably hampered (Dreyfus’) military career” and it is “indisputable that without this injustice, Alfred Dreyfus would naturally have risen to the highest ranks.” 

In a statement, the French Embassy in Israel said: “The French nation is committed to justice and does not forget. It is posthumously promoting Alfred Dreyfus to brigadier general — to correct a wrong, to honor a soldier, and to affirm that antisemitism, past or present, has no place in the Republic.” 

The degradation of Alfred Dreyfus
The degradation of Alfred DreyfusGallica

For those in need of a refresher on the Dreyfus Affair, French intelligence intercepted a memo from a French officer to a German embassy official in Paris in 1894. Suspicion fell on Dreyfus, who was tried by a military tribunal and convicted of treason. In January 1895, was stripped of his rank in a public degradation ceremony and sentenced to life imprisonment on Devil’s Island in French Guiana. 

The trial was fueled by widespread antisemitism within the military and French society. A public campaign to clear Dreyfus’ name soon emerged, led by journalist Bernard Lazare.

In 1896, new intelligence chief Lt. Col. Georges Picquart discovered that the real traitor was another officer, Maj. Ferdinand Walsin Esterhazy. 

Respected French novelist Émile Zola published his famous open letter, “J’accuse” (“I Accuse”), in January 1898, denouncing the military’s role in the miscarriage of justice. 

In 1906, France’s highest court overturned the conviction, fully exonerating Dreyfus. He was reinstated in the army as a major and went on to serve during World War I.  

Dreyfus died on 12 July 1935 at the age of 76, and the Dreyfus Affair became synonymous with the wrongful conviction of the innocent. It also remains one of France’s – and history’s – most enduring examples of institutional antisemitism. 

J'accuse...!
J’accuse…!Wikimedia Commons

The bill will be further debated on 2 June and if it is adopted, “it does not close the door on the strong symbol that would be the pantheonisation of Dreyfus,” according to historian Philippe Oriol, a specialist in the Dreyfus Affair – who refers to the Panthéon, the national necropolis reserved for the worship of illustrious men. 

“The idea is not to include a moment in history” in the Pantheon, but “to include a man”, added Oriol. 

“I can only regret that this promotion did not take place during his lifetime,” said Charles Dreyfus, grandson of Alfred Dreyfus. He told France Inter: “Most of the tributes paid to him were posthumous,” and how this gesture of reparation initiated by the parliamentarians remains a powerful symbol.  

“It is important to show what antisemitism can do.” 

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Newly discovered document adds evidence that Shroud of Turin is fake

ADVERTISEMENT The Shroud of Turin is one of the most treasured ancient artefacts, attracting countless tourists to the Italian city - despite the fact that the Cathedral of St. John the Baptist in Turin only publicly displays it on special occasions. Also known as the Holy Shroud, the linen cloth bears the faint image of

Original Harry Potter director on reboot series: ‘What’s the point?’

ADVERTISEMENT Chris Columbus, the celebrated American director of both Home Alone films, Mrs. Doubtfire and the first two Harry Potter films, has questioned the need to reboot the series with the upcoming HBO adaptation of J.K. Rowling’s novels. The filmmaker is currently promoting his Netflix film The Thursday Murder Club, which is based on the

Film of the Week: ‘Sorry, Baby’ – A masterful exploration of trauma

ADVERTISEMENT The scariest thing about life’s worst moments is the silence in which they often unfold. The world goes on, night falls, the windows of a suburban house glow as cars drive by. Yet for the person inside, existence has cracked; an irrevocable disconnect between who you once were, and the confused ghost you’ve become. 

From Taylor to Twin Peaks: The most iconic rings in pop culture

ADVERTISEMENT Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce have set the internet ablaze with news of their engagement, and all eyes have been on the ring.  According to US reports, Kelce worked with New York designer Kindred Lubeck of Artifex Fine Jewelry to design the ring and since the news of the engagement broke, the designer’s website has
- Advertisement -

165-million-year-old dinosaur with ‘weaponised tail’ found in Morocco

ADVERTISEMENT Scientists have unearthed the remains of a heavily armoured dinosaur, complete with rib spikes, a bony neck collar and a tail that may have doubled as a weapon. The fossil, discovered in Morocco’s Atlas Mountains, dates back 165 million years and belongs to a newly identified species of ankylosaur called Spicomellus. And this wasn’t

Why is Amsterdam’s Van Gogh Museum warning it may have to close?

ADVERTISEMENT Amsterdam's Van Gogh Museum, home to the world’s largest collection of works by Vincent van Gogh, has issued an extraordinary warning: without fresh government funding, it may be forced to shut its doors. The museum says a shortfall in state support threatens a €104m renovation plan - and with it the safety of the

Must read

Newly discovered document adds evidence that Shroud of Turin is fake

ADVERTISEMENT The Shroud of Turin is one of the most treasured ancient artefacts, attracting countless tourists to the Italian city - despite the fact that the Cathedral of St. John the Baptist in Turin only publicly displays it on special occasions. Also known as the Holy Shroud, the linen cloth bears the faint image of

Original Harry Potter director on reboot series: ‘What’s the point?’

ADVERTISEMENT Chris Columbus, the celebrated American director of both Home Alone films, Mrs. Doubtfire and the first two Harry Potter films, has questioned the need to reboot the series with the upcoming HBO adaptation of J.K. Rowling’s novels. The filmmaker is currently promoting his Netflix film The Thursday Murder Club, which is based on the
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you